English
Arabic
Similarly, the buyer may claim general damages in the event of rejection of non-conforming goods. If the seller has not yet delivered the goods and violates the contract, the buyer may withdraw from the contract. Note that the buyer may partially accept the goods, but will claim the amount by which the delivery is not compliant. As with the seller`s legal remedies, the amount of the damage should place the buyer in the same economic situation as it would have assumed if the contract had been properly performed as agreed. [36] For example, Josephine signed a contract to purchase a commercial lawn mower from Ace for $2,000. Ace ran out of mowers and broke in. If Josephine turns around and buys a comparable mower for $2,200, she can recoup Ace`s $200 price difference. If he misses the opportunity to buy a comparable mower for $2,200 and consequently loses $1,000 because he is unable to mow his customers` lawns, he will not be able to recover Ace`s lost profits because he had an economically reasonable “coverage option.” Sometimes a cash payment is not enough to give the buyer the benefit of his market. In this case, the buyer can request a “specific service” remedy, which means that the buyer asks the court to force the seller to hand over the contracted goods. Since monetary damages are the preferred means of contracting, a specific service is only available for “unique” goods when the money does not adequately convey the business advantage. Examples of cases where a particular service would be appropriate may therefore be contracts for the sale of unique works of art and custom works that would be difficult to reproduce. [37] There are three situations in which the Code provides remedies that are not the result of a breach.
These loss measures relate to insolvency. [5] According to the Code, insolvency occurs when a party is unable to pay its bills when due or its liabilities exceed its assets, which is defined in the Bankruptcy Act. [6] If the party does not manage its affairs properly, it will be deemed to have caused injury to the other party, thereby conferring rights in the goods that are the subject of the contract. [7] The seller is not obliged to attempt to resell undelivered goods if the buyer violates the contract. However, if the seller chooses to do so, he must comply with the provisions of the Code relating to resale. A seller who resells the undelivered goods in good faith and in a commercially reasonable manner may recover from the buyer the difference between a lower resale price and the original contract price as damages. [18] The seller must inform the buyer of its intention to resell in a private sale, and if it is resold in a public sale, it must also inform the buyer of the time and place of the public sale, unless the goods are perishable or depreciable. In the event of resale, the buyer is protected by the obligation to terminate so that he can control the resale price and the attribution of the resulting damage to the seller. [19] Thank you for participating in LawShelf`s video course on selling goods.
We hope that you now have a better understanding of the rules provided for in Article 2 of the Single Commercial Code, which governs all aspects of the sale of goods. We hope you will benefit from our other courses in commercial and contract law and encourage you to contact us if you have any questions or comments. Similar to our previous example, imagine Acme Home Improvement selling lawns and sports equipment. Acme orders 100 professional long fishing rods for $300 each from Barnacle`s Fishing Gear. Acme wanted fast stems, but was given slow-looking stems. This time, a court finds that Acme did not correctly specify the type of rods requested and that acme therefore violated payment for the goods. The contract price was $30,000 and the resale price of the fishing rods to another buyer was $29,000. Imagine, for example, Adrian`s Cars selling Bess an all-new red Chevrolet Cruze identified for $18,000. Adrian won $1,500 in the transaction because the price of his bill was $16,500. Bess violates and refuses to make the purchase.
The next day, Adrian sells the car to Eva for $18,000. Bess claims that Adrian did not suffer any damage because he was able to “cover” by selling to another buyer for the same price that Bess would have paid. Alternatively, a buyer who wishes to recover the goods directly can bring an action for recovery. [38] Replevin is available to a buyer if the buyer cannot use the cover for replacement goods, if the contract-specific goods are identified and if the buyer fulfils all its contractual obligations. [39] Adrian is a “lost volume seller” in this case. While it is true that he did not lose anything on the particularly identified car, if Bess had not reached an agreement, he could have sold the contracted car to Bess the next day and a similar car to Eva. Bess`s breach resulted in a loss of $1,500, as his trader was quite capable of making both trades if Bess had not been breached. As a result, he can recover $1,500 in damages from Bess. For example, suppose Josephine got her lawn mower from Ace for $2,000, but the lawn mower was broken. She could simply reject the mower and treat it as a violation.
Alternatively, if she spends $400 on parts and labor to fix the defective mower, she can get that $400 back from Ace. If she lost $500 in lost business during the time it took to make the repairs, it could result in indirect damages. If she rented a mower to stop it until the defective mower could be repaired, the rental cost could also be added as collateral damage. If the buyer is unable or decides not to do so, he may claim the difference between the contract price and the market price of the goods. [35] Damages expected under the Code include general, consequential and incidental damages. [3] Normally, punitive damages are not permitted in actions concerning the sale of goods. General damage is damage that relates to the goods in the contract, while indirect damage represents additional damage as a result of the breach. Incidental damage is incidental damage suffered by a party as a result of the breach. This damage is usually necessary to mitigate the damage suffered by the non-offending party, for example. B storage costs incurred by the buyer if the seller sends non-conforming goods. [4] For example, let`s say Acme Home Improvement sells lawns and sports equipment.
Acme orders 100 professional long fishing rods for $300 each from Barnacle`s Fishing Gear. Acme wanted fast-acting rods that bend at the top of the bar when pressure is applied, but instead received slow-acting rods where the bar bends more towards its base. A court found that Acme had duly specified the type of fishing rods it wanted and that Barnacle was violating the shipment of non-compliant goods. Barnacle would be liable to Acme for any damage. An infringing buyer may receive a refund of funds paid to the seller for goods detained by the seller. However, the seller may deduct the damages agreed in the contract. If the damages are not specified in the agreement, the code provides that the seller can deduct twenty percent of the total value of the performance of the contract or $500, whichever is lower. The seller can also compensate for the benefits that the buyer has received from the contract.
[17] In the event of a breach by the buyer, the seller has different remedies depending on the delivery status of the goods. Before delivery, the seller may terminate the contract and stop delivery. The seller can then resell the goods. [11] The seller can then recover the difference between the resale price and the contract price or, alternatively, recover the difference between the market price and the contract price if the goods are not resold. Alternatively, the seller could choose to recover the lost profits from the sale or, if it cannot be resold, recover the full contract price. Imagine, for example, ace refusing to sell Josephine her lawn mower under contract, and Josephine simply cannot find another comparable mower available in time to serve her customers. .